Should You Buy Last Year’s Phone?

Check support first

Last year’s flagship suits most buyers who need a phone, provided it has enough security support left. Keep your current phone if it still works well.

Every year a new phone launches with a slightly better camera, a slightly faster chip and a much higher price than the one it replaces. And every year, the phone it replaces gets cheaper overnight while staying exactly as good as it was the day before.

So here’s a question that could save you a few hundred dollars: do you need this year’s phone at all?

What actually changes from year to year

Phones used to leap forward with each release. Screens doubled in sharpness, cameras went from poor to good, and batteries gained hours. Those days are mostly over. Year-on-year changes are now small.

A typical update brings:

  • A processor that’s faster in benchmarks, in ways most people can’t feel while messaging, browsing and scrolling.
  • A camera that’s a little better in low light or at zoom.
  • A slightly brighter screen.
  • A new color.
  • A few software features, many of which reach older models too.

Put last year’s flagship next to this year’s and use both for a week. Most people would struggle to say which was which.

The case for last year’s model

The price. When a new model arrives, the old one usually drops in price, and retailers discount remaining stock further. You’re getting what was the best phone in the world twelve months ago for a good deal less.

Known quality. A phone that’s been out for a year has been thoroughly reviewed. Any battery problems, camera quirks or faults have come to light. A brand-new model is still a bit of an unknown.

Cheaper accessories. Cases, screen protectors and chargers for last year’s phone are everywhere and cost less.

Last year’s flagship usually beats this year’s mid-range. For the same money, a year-old top model typically has a better camera, a better screen and a sturdier build than a brand-new cheaper phone.

The one catch: software updates

This is the thing to check before buying any older phone, and it matters more than the camera or the chip.

A phone stays safe to use only while it gets security updates. Once they stop, new security holes stay open, and over time banking apps and others may stop working.

Every phone has an update clock, and it starts when the model is released, not when you buy it. A phone that launched a year ago has already used a year of its support.

The good news is that update policies have improved a great deal.

  • Google promises seven years of updates on its recent Pixel phones.
  • Samsung promises seven years on its recent flagship Galaxy phones, and several years on many mid-range ones.
  • Apple has a long record of supporting iPhones for five years or more.
  • Other brands vary a lot. Some budget phones get only two or three years.

With seven years of support, losing one to buy last year’s model hardly matters. With three years of support, it matters a lot. Search for the exact model with the words “update policy” and count how many years are left.

Find the policySearch for the exact model.
Check the releaseSupport starts at launch.
Count what remainsCheck how many years of updates are left.

When the new one is worth it

Sometimes the newest model is the right buy.

  • A feature you’ve been waiting for has arrived. A much better zoom camera, a big jump in battery life or a design change you care about.
  • You keep phones for a very long time. If you’ll use it for six or seven years, the extra year of updates and the newer chip are worth more to you.
  • The prices are close. Sometimes carrier deals or trade-in offers make the new model nearly as cheap as the old one. Then there’s no reason to buy the older phone.
  • Your work depends on it. If the camera or the performance earns you money, small improvements can pay off.
Consider the latest
  • A feature you have been waiting for
  • You keep phones for many years
  • Your work relies on the improvement
Consider last year’s flagship
  • Camera and screen still meet your needs
  • You want to read established reviews

What about two or three years old?

Going back further saves more, with more caveats.

  • Check the update clock carefully. This is where short-support phones run out.
  • Consider the battery. A phone that’s been sitting in a warehouse is fine. A used one has a worn battery, so check its health or budget for a replacement.
  • Buy from a seller with a warranty. Refurbished phones from reputable sellers come tested, with a guarantee and often a new battery.

Much of the advice in Are Refurbished Laptops Worth It? applies to phones as well.

Or keep the phone you have

Here’s the cheapest option, and the one no advert will suggest. If your current phone still gets updates and its only real problem is a battery that dies by mid-afternoon, a battery replacement costs a fraction of a new phone and can make it feel new again.

Running out of storage? Clearing out old videos and unused apps is free. A cracked screen can usually be replaced. A new case can make a tired phone feel fresh. The longer you keep a working phone, the less it costs you per year, and the less ends up as waste.

Battery runs outReplace the battery

Consider this if updates are still coming.

Storage fills upClear space

Remove old videos and unused apps.

Screen cracksCheck repair

A cracked screen can usually be replaced.

A quick guide

Your situationBest move
Your phone works and still gets updatesKeep it. Replace the battery if needed
You need a new phone and want valueLast year’s flagship
You keep phones for six or more yearsThis year’s model with a long update promise
You’re on a tight budgetA refurbished flagship, two years old, with a warranty
Prices are nearly the sameThe newer one

The bottom line

For most people, last year’s phone is the smart buy. It does the same things, costs less and comes with a year of real-world reviews. Check how many years of updates it has left, compare the actual prices on the day, and don’t let a launch event convince you that the phone in your pocket has stopped working.

You can compare options at different budgets on our Best Phones by Price page. And if a sale price looks too good, our guide to spotting a fake deal applies to phones as much as laptops.